5 Comments

One of the striking things about this inheritance tax row is just how very, very bad the government has been at putting its case and rebutting the right-wing press, NFU, Conservative Party and other predictable opponents, none of whom are ever going to support Labour. Starmer commented this weekend - I believe, for the first time - that actually, if the landowner is married, and if proper estate planning is carried out, the threshold for paying will be more than £2million (he said £3m: I’m not sure how he got to that figure, but I have seen from experts like Dan Neidle and Paul Lewis calculations comfortably exceeding £2m).The most cogent principled argument for the tax came not from Number 10 or 11, but from Will Hutton in this week’s Observer. But most voters will have been left with the impression that this is a tax on all farmers - rather than, as is the case, a tax on a few hundred per year extremely rich people - whose assets place them in the top 3 or 4% of wealth in this country. And most voters will also not have been told that this exemption for farmers, far from being some sort of ancient rural birthright for the noble sons of the soil, only came in during Mrs Thatcher’s time as PM.

Expand full comment

Yes, the Will Hutton article put the argue very well. This government isn’t very good at teaching the electorate about its policies. It needs to up its game.

Expand full comment

We never forget how the austerity measures beloved of the Tories, together with their predilection for scooping cash towards their cronies, donors and their own back pockets while they sold off working law courts and everything they could: utilities, water maintenance, transport, to name only a few of their reckless and careless destruction of any good in UK life. Don't forget all those they allowed to die (Covid, NHS restrictions by being starved of money) as well as the scandals like Post Office, IPP, Blood scandal and more. They should learn to see people as individuals, not objects.

Expand full comment

I suppose it is possible that Laura Trott does believe that Labour’s tuition fee rise amounts to a declaration of war on students, but that she doesn't want to reverse it. Maybe she's a Student War Hawk.

Expand full comment

I don’t follow the news very much so I’m delighted to learn that the new shadow education secretary is an MP called Laura Trott. Somehow both delicious nominative contra-determinism and the sort of name given to the main antagonist in a Dickens novel.

Expand full comment